Orange Creamsicle Creami

No ratings yet

This post may contain affiliate links. Please see our disclosure policy for more details.

With summer here and temperatures soaring, a cold treat always sounds good! Enter this new Orange Creamsicle Creami recipe for those hot days and the perfect way to cool down. I always love using my Ninja Cream, but it comes in extra handy during these hot summer months!

Orange Creamsicle Creami showing protein ice cream, orange slices, whipped cream and orange zest.


Makes 1 Creami

Serving size: 1 Creami

363 cals

39.2p / 35.3c / 6.9f (0.5 fiber)

How to Find in the MyFitnessPal or MacrosFirst App

Search the food database in either app for, Stay Fit Mom Orange Creamsicle Creami

Orange Creamsicle Creami ingredients showing milk protein powder, and orange juice concentrate.


  • 1 & 1/2 cups 2% milk (I like to use Fairlife)
  • 1 scoop Clean Simple Eats simply vanilla whey protein
  • 3 tablespoons frozen orange juice concentrate
Orange Creamsicle Creami showing step by step process.

This post contains affiliate links.  If you purchase something from these links, we could earn a small commission.  This would be at no additional cost to you.​​​​​​​

Supplies Used

Ninja Creami–I have this 7 in 1 and it does everything I need. I prefer the smaller cups compared to the Ninja Creami Deluxe machine and cups that are twice as big.

Extra Cups–I have 10 cups and it makes prepping these creami for the week for multiple people so much easier! Not necessary, but definitely nice to have!

Hand Blender–I love using this to mix up my Creamis before I freeze them. A frother isn’t quite powerful enough and using the blender is a pain because then you just have more dishes to wash!

Insulated Cup Sleeves– I don’t have these exact sleeves but we have some homemade ones from grandma we love using so our hands don’t get cold while enjoying our Creami!

Important Ninja Creami Tip

If you have an off centered lump on the top of your frozen creami, use a knife to flatten it out as best you can before spinning it in the machine. I’ve learned the hard way that an off centered bubble will cause the paddle attachment to come off the rod and break your machine!! (Ninja did replace my creami in both instances, but it was still a hassle so I want to warn you!)

Orange Creamsicle Creami showing protein ice cream, orange slices, whipped cream and orange zest.

Can I Use Any Milk?

I always use Fairlife milk because it’s extra creami, lactose free, and just makes for the best ice cream in my opinion. The fat free, 2%, and chocolate Fairlife are all amazing in the creami machine. I’ve tried other milks, but it’s always more icy. If you have an allergy I suggest experimenting and finding what milk you like best.

Can I Make this in a Blender?

Of course! It won’t turn out super creamy and ice cream like of course, but it will still taste really great! I would suggest adding a few frozen banana pieces and ice for a thicker shake in the blender.

Orange Creamsicle Creami showing protein ice cream, orange slices, whipped cream and orange zest.

Can I refreeze My Creami If I don’t finish it?

if you don’t finish eating your Orange Creamsicle Creami, flatten the top as best you can and place back in the freezer. Use the respin option on the Ninja Creami when ready to eat.

My Favorite Protein Powder

Clean Simple Eats is my favorite protein powder and the only brand I use to make my creamis. Save 10% on all flavors of protein from CSE with discount code STAYFITMOM.

Here are my top 5 favorite flavors I use consistently to make my protein creamis:

  1. Simply Vanilla
  2. Brownie Batter
  3. Coconut Cream Whey Protein Powder
  4. Mint Cookie
  5. Cake Batter


You can store any uneaten Orange Creamsicle Creami by smoothing the top as well as you can in the pint, putting the lid back on, and returning to the freezer. When you’re ready to eat the rest, take it from the freezer and use the re-spin option on the Ninja Creami.

Stay Fit Mom Creami Recipes

  1. Dragon Fruit Protein Creami

And more to comer!!!

Get the Stay Fit Mom Cookbooks!

Macros included for all recipes and pre loaded in the apps for easy macro tracking!

Digital and hardcopies available!

No ratings yet

Orange Creamsicle Creami

A light, refreshing Creami that tastes like an orange creamsicle!
Prep: 3 minutes
Freeze Time: 12 hours
Servings: 1 Creami
Want to save this recipe?
Just enter your email and get it sent to your inbox! Plus you’ll get new recipes from us every week!


  • 1.5 cups 2% milk, I like to use Fairlife
  • 1 scoop Clean Simple Eats simply vanilla whey protein
  • 3 tablespoons frozen orange juice concentrate


  • Add all ingredients to the ninja creami cup and blend well with a hand held blender.
  • Let sit out 3-5 minutes to let the bubbles settle. Cover with lid and place in the freezer at least 12 hours or preferably overnight.
  • Place frozen ice cream in a bowl of hot water for 60 seconds to defrost the sides of the cup.
  • Place in the ninja creami machine and press the lite ice cream button.
  • Respin a second time by pressing the repsin button. Repeat as the respin button as many times as needed until you get the consistency you like.
  • Mix in or top with any toppings you like. For this one I like to occasionally top with some whip cream or fresh fruit.


-Let your creamis sit out on the counter a minimum of 5 minutes after mixing for the freezer, to let the bubbles settle.
-Don’t skimp on soaking your creami for 60 seconds in hot water before spinning. This will help eliminate slushy sides.
-Add 1 tablespoon of milk when spinning your creami if it’s too powdery after multiple re-spins.
-Clean your Creami lid and the bottom of the rod on the machine really well after each use. If you don’t you’ll get gunk build up and it will begin to smell.
Find in Myfitnesspal and the Macrosfirst app food database by searching, “Stay Fit Mom Orange Creamsicle Creami


Serving: 1Creami, Calories: 363kcal, Carbohydrates: 35.3g, Protein: 39.2g, Fat: 6.9g, Fiber: 0.5g
Like this recipe? Rate and comment below!

You Might Also Like

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating